[ back ]
Day 24, At Sea

Today they have another exercise.   These are important for the safety of the passengers, it is important that crew are well trained and practised to handle any emergency; but these are not well organised at all and come thick and fast.   There is a three channel switch in the cabin.   I found out by phoning reception that channel 1 has Muzac on it.   None of them are labelled, and there is no information in the guest book about them. There is also a volume control so you can turn down the volume on shore excursion announcements if you don't need them.   However when they do a drill they output all the announcements on all three channels and disable the volume control so that everyone hears them at full volume, wanted or not.

While this may be appropriate action in a real emergency it is not necessary for every practice, of which there are several in cruise.   What they should do is use channel 2 for exercises and reserve the use of all three channels in parallel for real emergencies.   That way guests can turn off the annoying, intrusive tannoy interruptions but still receive important announcements by selecting channel 3, channel 1 if they wanted the Muzac, or channel 2 if they wanted to monitor the progress of the exercise.   The cruise line would probably argue that it is necessary to test all the equipment as it would be used in a real emergency, but this only needs to be done once on a cruise, not on every single exercise, which should concentrate on crew training. Exercises should be designed to improve safety, not as a bureaucratic procedure to be followed without any thought.   It is like auditors insisting that password rules must be complicated so that passwords can't be guessed, which results in users writing the passwords down and pasting them on their terminals.

[ prev   top   next ]